Indeed, your clamping system will directly affect the vibrations produced during the cut. These vibrations are significantly related to the quality of the cuts, the longevity of the tool and the noise generated by your machine.
However, clamping systems are various and making a good choice isn't an easy task. The following article will compare 8 different types of clamping systems and classify them in terms of safety, cost, ergonomy, adaptability and compatibility with different working areas.
1 - Wood Screws
2 - Composite Nails
4 - Toggle Clamps
5 - Step Blocks
6 - Excentric Clamps
7 - Vacuum Pads
8 - Vacuum Table
Be aware that the following examples focus on kit frame-CNC machines, we are not dealing with industrial machines.
1 - Wood Screws
Attaching a workpiece on your spoilerboard with wood screws doesn’t really need any explanation, but it’s worth to compare it with other systems.
To summarize, screws are not the perfect way to clamp a part if you work daily on your CNC router, but we definitely recommend working with this system if you begin with CNC machines. You will have time to think about improving your clamping system once have made all the classical mistakes and your CNC skills improved.
Pros
really cheap and easy to set up
provides a strong and secure clamping
adapted to (almost) any workpiece height
Cons
damages the board quickly
can't be used for surfacing operations
2 - Composite Nails
If you're working with wood, a composite nailer might be the perfect solution for you.
Its main advantage is that composite nails will prevent from damaging your bit if you made an error in the G-code.
We're one of the sole reseller of this solution in EU, and you can find our Raptor/Omer nailer here.
Pros
really fast
provides a strong and secure clamping
no risk of damaging your mills
allow to mill the entire surface
Cons
can't be used with every material
there's an initial investment needed
3 - Double-sided Tape
Using double-sided tape is one of the easiest ways to clamp a part. It’s pretty straightforward: cover the bottom of your stock with tape and stick it to the working surface.
- When working with sheets of metal or very thin wooden sheets that cannot be easily clamped with another system.
- When you don’t want to leave tabs on your work for a perfect finishing. You need to be sure that the sticking surface of your part will be big enough for it to stay in place once cut from your stock.
Pros
really cheap and easy to set up
very useful for sheets or parts without tabs
Cons
not very secure - can be dangerous
doesn't work with every type of job
4 - Toggle Clamps
Pros
the quickest clamp/release system
can clamp different workpiece thicknesses (with adjustment)
Cons
not ergonomic if the workpiece thickness changes too oftensuitable almost only with T-slot frames
doesn't allow surfacing operations
5 - Step Blocks
If you're not planning on cutting very hard material, you can also mill these clamps yourself, to the size and thickness you wish, in many materials, such as plywood, aluminium or hard plastic. We’ve made a tutorial series on how to mill a simple plywood double screw clamp that you can find here.
Pros
easy to clamp and release the workpiece
can clamp (almost) any thickness
robust and secure system
can be milled to fit your needs
Cons
suitable only with T-slot or threaded insertsdoesn't allow surfacing operations
6 - Excentric Clamps
Their main disadvantage is that they require T-slots or a threaded insert grid to be used. You’ll also need a bunch of them to be sure your part is secured.
Pros
easy to clamp and release the workpiece
can clamp any thickness
robust and secure system
can be milled to fit your needs
Cons
suitable only with T-slot or threaded inserts7 - Vacuum Clamps
This system simply consists of several pads, which can be moved and attached to your working area. They are connected to a vacuum pump that will suck your workpiece, keeping it firmly clamped.
Pros
fastest clamping system
can clamp any thickness
robust and secure system
Cons
expensive8 - Vacuum Table
Pros
fastest clamping system
can clamp any thickness
robust and secure system
Cons
very expensivecan't clamp every material